Meet Caniglia Real Estate Group: The Top Real Estate Agents in Park County, Colorado

No one knows Alma, Fairplay and the whole Park County area better than the longest-standing real estate agency in town!

About Caniglia Real Estate Group

Caniglia Real Estate Group has connected property owners with the joys of Colorado living for more than 25 years. Founded and led by award-winning REALTOR® Amy Caniglia in 1999, our group came together to be the area’s authoritative source on all things living, working, and vacationing in the Park County area.

With extensive knowledge of Park County communities like Alma, Fairplay, and Jefferson, as well as nearby skiing hotspots like Breckenridge and Frisco, we help clients make informed decisions. Whether you’re buying a cabin, selling a piece of land, or want to make the high country your forever home, Caniglia Real Estate Group guides you through the process of turning your dreams into reality.

01. Our Listings

Find Your Dream Park County Home

Explore all of Our Listings

Why choose Caniglia Real Estate Group?

A Reputation for Professionalism

When you work with Caniglia Real Estate, you know you’ll get clear, consistent communication and first-rate customer service. We balance drive and dedication with patience and compassion. If you have questions, we know how to find the answers. After all, we want you to enjoy the home-buying process!

Local Expertise from Alma’s Real Estate Office

As the only real estate office in town with a physical location, the Caniglia Real Estate team has local knowledge you can’t get with an out-of-town agent. Our REALTORS® can help you find your dream home and your new favorite local hiking trail, fishing spot, or lunch spot.

Alma isn’t just where we work. We know the community so well because we live and play here too — and that’s why no one knows Park County better. We love the mountain weather, outdoor life, and quiet pace of Park County and we want to help you live that life, too.

02. Our Brokers

Meet Our Rockstar Real Estate Agents

Amy Caniglia

Caniglia Real Estate’s founder is trusted for her expertise, honesty, and encyclopedic knowledge of the Colorado housing market.

Voted REALTOR® of the Year by the Summit Association of REALTORS® Board of Directors
Certifications include Resort and Second Home Property Specialist and Certified Residential Specialist

Ask Amy about: the best trails in the National Forest

Learn More About Amy

Bonnie Paffenroth

As a 25-year resident of Alma, Bonnie is passionate about Park County’s idyllic outdoor lifestyle.

In-depth knowledge of Park County’s diverse real estate opportunities
A relentless commitment to client satisfaction

Ask about: tips on where to ski

Learn More About Bonnie

Lisa Kunst

Lisa’s attention to detail and personable approach makes her an asset to any client, from new home buyers to those looking for a second property.

Nearly three decades of sales experience
Celebrated for her exceptional communication

Ask about: where to go on the water

Learn More About Lisa

Marilee Devries

Marilee’s energy and unwavering perseverance translate to a seamless homebuying experience for her clients.

Broad experience in the real estate industry
Insightful local guidance, delivered with a helpful demeanor

Ask about: the best spot for sustainable goods

Learn More About Marilee

03. Explore

Properties We Sell

Residential & Cabins

Find the right place to call home. Work with one of our agents to find the right place to vacation or call home year-round.

View Properties

Land

If you want to break ground on something special and truly yours, we’ll help you find the perfectly-situated, right-sized plot.

View Land

Commercial

Starting a business here? Let us be the first to congratulate you! We’ll help you find the best property for your venture.

View Properties

04. Testimonials

Read Testimonials from Happy Clients

We’ve worked with Amy on three transactions to date - all of which have been incredibly smooth! She is incredibly patient and knows the local area extremely well. Amy and her team are excellent - highly rated and would do business with again, no question.

Thomas H.

Caniglia Real Estate assisted us in the sale of our cabin in Placer Valley. Amy responded to our request for a meeting promptly and toured the property, Bonnie met with the photographer to get photos processed and the listing was placed online. The first offer came in the next day, with 7 more to follow! Cabin was sold in 3 days!!! Amy and Bonnie were so helpful in every step of the way... We highly recommend using them for your real estate needs.

Terry H.

Wow!! What an experience we had selling our cabin in Alma! We thank you for your guidance and expertise in this process. We know you put a lot of your time and energy into it, from dealing with Park County to the septic company. Who knew we'd get so many offers for our little piece of paradise! You told us that you would have it sold by summer's end - mission accomplished!

T & C Hall

Caniglia Group rocks! [They] sold my house [in] 3 days for over asking price. They are knowledgeable [and] easy to work with.

Mark D.

Most professional and helpful realtor EVER!!! We told her what we were looking for and she produced. Even came up with homes we had not seen on the internet. Always had more information than we needed. She kept us informed and on schedule through the entire process.

M.N.H.

We have bought and sold 17 plus homes over the years. Amy is absolutely the best realtor we have ever worked with. She has a very positive attitude and communication skills, has great follow thru and exceptional attention to detail. Amy certainly exceeded our expectations!!

Les K.

Amy helped us find the perfect mountain getaway. She is very knowledgeable about the area and spent time showing us different neighborhoods so we could have more context when looking at online listings. This was extremely helpful when trying to buy a home in a competitive market while living outside the area. She also scheduled a viewing for a home she thought we would like the day it was listed (before we asked), and it ended up being the winner!

Kelly B.

We had an amazing experience working with Caniglia Real Estate! From start to finish, they exceeded our expectations in every way. Amy's patience, knowledge, and professionalism made the entire process smooth and stress-free. What we appreciated the most was how they were never pushy, always taking the time to listen to our needs and concerns. Communication was consistently clear and timely, making us feel supported every step of the way. Without a doubt, Amy Caniglia and her entire team at Caniglia Real Estate are the best realtors in Park County (and beyond), and we highly recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. Thank you for everything!

Jane S.

Me and my wife had a great experience with Marilee… She treated us like family and made us feel comfortable and confident our property decisions. Thanks again Marilee!

Harold H.

We were fortunate enough to have Lisa Kunst as our agent on two transactions in Colorado. She is simply amazing, very professional, extremely knowledgeable, helpful, and goes well beyond the duty of an agent helping us buy and sell a property there. I cannot say enough kind things about all she did for us. She was just simply fantastic.

Greg M.

This is the absolutely best real estate agency you can find! They made the most awesome listing when we were selling our house. We got so many showings and sold! They are knowledgeable, helpful, prompt, and make sure everything is on track. We have used them for several transactions and have only the best things to say about them. If you need a realtor, I strongly recommend the Caniglia group!

Gisela V.

Lisa is very professional with strong attention to detail. She kept me well-informed throughout the process. All documents were timely and correct and the closing process smooth. Her extensive contacts and area network brought a premium price for my property! I can't recommend Lisa enough!

David P.

05. Contact Us

Get in touch with Caniglia Real Estate Group

Get Started Today