Our Brokers

Meet our professional team at Caniglia Real Estate Group:

Amy Caniglia – Owner Broker

Amy moved from Upstate New York to Colorado in 1994 with a BS in Marketing and Business Management. After living in the Vail Valley for 5 years, she made Park County her home.

She became a Realtor in 1999 and founded Caniglia Real Estate Group in 2005, the entire time focusing on the greater Alma/Fairplay area. Today, a dozen years later, Amy is trusted for her expertise, honesty and knowledge in the local real estate market.

Contact Amy: 303-870-6446 or amy@canigliagroup.com


Bonnie Paffenroth – Broker Associate

In 2003, after the sale of her successful landscaping business of 13 years, Bonnie decided to start her new career in real estate. Bonnie’s knowledge of business has enabled her to focus on the many commercial real estate opportunities. Her dedication to commitment and detail are just a couple of her strengths that attribute to her success.

When not working, Bonnie can be found skiing or hiking with her dogs, Oscar & Zulu.

Contact Bonnie: 970.406.1610 or bonnie@canigliagroup.com


Don Gostisha – Broker Associate

Don has lived in Alma for over 30 years and has been an expert in our local real estate market for 17 of those years. He knows this area like the back of his hand.  We consider him our “local historian” and we continue to learn stories about our area from him!

Don’s in depth knowledge and dedication to his clients’ best interests is certainly an asset for anyone working with him and why we value him on our team.

Contact Don: 719.838.0795 or don@canigliagroup.com


Nancy Shelton – Broker Associate

Nancy’s goal is to save her clients time, money and worry in their real estate transactions. She knows that it is important to work with someone who has enthusiasm, desire and determination and this is driven by her commitment to her clients. Your investment is her priority.

Nancy looks forward to having you call on her experience and creative thinking to guide you through the process.  She is certain that you will enjoy this area as much as she has for the last 15 years!

Contact Nancy: 970.389.7404 or nancy@canigliagroup.com


Naesa Robertson – Broker Associate

Naesa moved to the Denver Metro area from Soldotna, Alaska in 2000. In 2003 Naesa began a career in Real Estate. Energetic and diligent in her labors, she found much success and gratification selling the metropolitan Denver area, but the lure of the mountains was not to be overlooked. So Naesa and her husband, who shares her love for wildlife and the outdoors, decided to relocate.

They now find themselves firmly entrenched in our local community.

Contact Naesa: 970-393-0909 or naesa@canigliagroup.com

Be sure to stay in the loop on all the exciting local real estate news by reading our ‘Real Estate Blog’.